On Thursday, Leon Panetta held a press conference announcing what he
called "cuts" to military spending. The first question following his
remarks pointed out that the "cuts" are to dream budgets, while the
actual spending will be increased over Panetta's 10-year plan.
Is there
any year, the reporter asked, out of the 10 years in question, other
than the first one, 2013, in which spending will actually decrease at
all. Panetta replied that he was proposing really truly to cut the
projected dream budgets that he had hoped for. In other words, he did
not answer the question.
Now, there are additional minor cuts "on
the table" as the saying goes, cuts that Panetta has described as
disastrous, cuts that would take U.S. military spending back to about
2007 levels, cut nowhere close to what a majority of the country
favors.
(How we survived 2007 and all the years preceding it has never been
explained.) Earlier this week, Republican members of the House Armed
Services Committee sent President Obama a video denouncing these cuts.
They are, of course, the cuts mandated by the legislation that created
the Super Committee, which failed, resulting in supposedly automatic
cuts.
The video (
available here)
is itself packed with lies. It falsely claims that cuts have already
been made. It uses dollar figures derived from lumping 10 years of
budgets together to make cuts sound 10 times larger. It pretends the
automatic cuts would all be to the military, whereas many could be to
the State Department and other subsidiary arms of the military. These
Republicans propose slashing 10% of non-military government jobs and
describe this as saving jobs, even though non-military spending produces
more jobs for the same dollars than military spending does. And of
course there is no mention in this video or in any official discussion
of exactly how
outrageously huge
the U.S. military has become. But a crazy video, and a bill to go with
it, can not only pass the House and make its way into the Senate
(Senator John McCain is already working on companion legislation), but
the President is already in agreement with this bill's primary purpose
of undoing any actual cuts to the military. The history of lame duck
officials, by the way, is that of becoming less, not more,
representative of the public will. Caveat emptor!
In 2004, three
times in three debates Senator John McCain proposed cutting military
spending and Obama avoided the topic. Candidate Obama proposed
significantly enlarging the largest military the world had ever seen.
And he has done so. He now proposes not to cut it while pretending to
cut it. The best bit of rhetoric in this week's State of the Union
address was this:
"Take the money we're no longer spending at war, use half of it to
pay down our debt, and use the rest to do some nation-building right
here at home."